Friday, December 20, 2019

Republicans fail their first test of the Beshear administration

It's been a busy week in education circles in Kentucky, and none of the news has been good for those of us who are hoping to see major improvement and reform in our schools.

On his first day in office, Gov. Andy Beshear dissolved the existing state Board of Education, created a new one, and appointed a number of liberal opponents of school reform and defenders of the status quo. All but one of the members of the ousted board filed a lawsuit that day and sought an injunction to halt the action until the case is decided.

The following day, the new board met and forced the resignation of Wayne Lewis, the state's education commissioner. That day and the next, the lawsuit plaintiffs lost their bids for an injunction in Franklin Circuit Court, the Court of Appeals, and the Supreme Court, meaning the new board will remain in place until the court case is completed, which may take a year or two.

So, after all this occurred, what happened? Republican legislative leaders waited until all the controversy had subsided, then issued a statement criticizing Beshear's decision.

The old saying goes that talk is cheap. So, the statements by Senate President Robert Stivers and House Education Chair Regina Huff can be judged worthless. They accomplished nothing. "Cowardly" would be an appropriate adjective.

If these Republican leaders were really as unhappy as they claimed, they should have done something earlier in the week instead of just saying something on Friday.

Why didn't they seek to intervene in the lawsuit filed by the ousted board members? Why not file an amicus brief and ask to be heard by the courts? Stivers is an attorney. He could have written the brief and argued the motion himself.

This was an ideal opportunity for the GOP-controlled legislature to show that it will not allow the new Democrat governor to run over it, and that it will stand up for conservative principles in the face of the new liberal onslaught directed from the office on the back side of the first floor of the Capitol. But in its first test of the next four years, Republicans failed miserably.

Perhaps the Senate has something up its sleeve. Maybe it plans to reject Beshear's reorganization when it comes up for approval in that chamber when the General Assembly convenes next month. But that comes too late for Wayne Lewis, who's already taken a job at Belmont University in Tennessee. The legislature had its opportunity to take an early, bold stand last week when the ousted board members went to court, but it squandered it.

It's already been pointed out why conservatives should look upon the GOP-controlled legislature with skepticism. Last week's failure to act when the opportunity was there for a strong stance does not inspire confidence.

It's shaping up to be a long four years for Kentucky.