Chasing down rumors in the age of stenography

As someone with two degrees in journalism, and someone who worked as a newspaper reporter and editor for nearly 15 years, I believe I'm as well-qualified as anyone to critique the news industry. Even before my ideological awakening in the 1990s, the biases inherent in most news coverage were apparent. Once I became aware of what to look for, it's even more obvious.

When you look at the way the mainstream press treats Democrats and liberals, as opposed to Republicans and conservatives, how can you not conclude that the mainstream press plays favorites and has an agenda? The ongoing coronavirus situation has provided ample proof.

Even before the "kung flu" Wuhan Chinese virus became a factor, it was noticeable. Contrast how the Washington press corp treated Barack Obama and the way it treats Donald Trump. Or in Kentucky, look at how Ernie Fletcher and Matt Bevin were scrutinized vs. the coverage of Steve and Andy Beshear.

For several weeks, with only a few exceptions, Gov. Andy Beshear has conducted a daily briefing and press conference. He gets free air time all across Kentucky on multiple television stations. A handful of reporters are present. After the governor leads everyone in a ritualistic chant of "We will get through this; we will get through this together," rah-rahs and praises those who are taking his orders and recommendations to heart, gives a briefing on new COVID-19 cases, and has staffers give updates on connected issues such as unemployment filings, he takes questions from the smattering of reporters in the room. There's always a deferential air from the press corps. There are no raised voices, no hostility, no "gotcha" questions -- no hard questions at all, really. The assembled "journalists" are really acting as little more than stenographers, relaying the governor's message unchallenged.

When you see members of the press adding phrases like "Stay Home" or putting cute little mask emojis in their Twitter handles, or urging viewers to "stay healthy at home" when they sign out of newscasts, you know they aren't interested in questioning the government, but instead acting as adjunct press secretaries.

Contrast that with the briefings and press conferences held by President Trump. Reporters are hostile. They're antagonistic. They shout and yell. They raise questions on subjects totally unrelated to the coronavirus. They do not behave in a respectful manner. The White House correspondents certainly don't act like their Frankfort counterparts. Is it possible that the political party of the executive has something to do with it?

Remember how former Gov. Bevin was treated by the press? He certainly didn't get the respect that Andy Beshear is getting. Even now, with Bevin out of office, reporters seem to take a perverse joy in attacking him.

Since Gov. Beshear ordered businesses closed, instituted travel bans and prohibitions on gatherings, criticized other states for not closing up shop the way we've been made to do, and told Kentuckians to stay home unless absolutely necessary, at least three troublesome rumors have circulated. One of them seems to have some evidence to back it up, but the other two are merely speculation at this point. You'd think a competent and attentive press corps would ask him to address them, but so far nothing from the Joe Sonkas or Daniel Desrochers or Phil Pendletons of the world.

The first incident happened a few weeks ago, when various reports circulated that a state police detail took Beshear's daughter from the Governor's Mansion in Frankfort to a friend's house on Brownsboro Road in Louisville for a play date. This was at the height of the "Healthy at Home" edict when people were being told not to interact with others outside their households for social reasons. Indeed, the noncompliance reporting logs are full of entries of children from different households playing together.

The second incident centers on the controversial Memorial Day weekend rallies at the Capitol and Governor's Mansion. Even as protestors approached the mansion, it was being said that the governor and his family were not home at the time. Rumors swirled that they were vacationing in Florida; this after he had been frequently urging Kentuckians not to travel out of state to places that had reopened at a faster pace. Beshear stated in his briefing Tuesday, the first one after the incident, that his family was not home at the time, but he didn't say where they were, and no reporter bothered to ask where they were.

Finally, late last week, the state unveiled plans for restarting youth sports activities. Like most of the guidelines for reopening, they are limited with onerous restrictions. Included in the rules for youth baseball were admonishments against the popular travel baseball and softball teams that go to other cities, counties, and even states. Some intrepid online sleuth found out that not only is Beshear's son a member of a traveling baseball team based out of Louisville, but the squad is scheduled to play in Indiana later this summer.

Surely, with these rumors floating hot and heavy over social media, the press would ask the governor about them, right? Nope. Instead, they recently chased down an unfounded and unsubstantiated rumor that Bevin had fathered a child with one of his former staff members -- a rumor that was pushed (if not started) by the members of the pro-Beshear, anti-Bevin KY 120 United teachers group. This is the group, remember, that organized the illegal teacher sickouts to protest the efforts to preserve educators' pensions.

If the governor is constantly saying, "you can't be doing that," yet is doing the things he says others shouldn't do, would it not be incumbent upon the press to ask about those things? If reporters heard, and wrote about, the Bevin affair, surely they've heard the rumors about Beshear's hypocritical acts. Which is more newsworthy? A scurrilous personal rumor about a former elected official, or the possibility of the current governor adopting a "do as I say not as I do" philosophy?

But as long as the press corps acts as stenographers for the governor, answers won't be forthcoming. It may take citizen journalists filing open records requests for details about travel records to determine if state personnel took the governor's daughter to Louisville to play with a friend, or if a state aircraft and personnel were used to fly the governor's family to Florida. And even then, the press can't be counted on to do anything with the information others may obtain. During the Ernie Fletcher administration, bloggers uncovered evidence showing bias in the prosecution of him and his aides. Evidence of a compromised grand jury was known by the journalists of the time, yet they did nothing to bring that news to a wide audience. Only those of us who kept up with things through alternative sources knew.

In the meantime, we can expect the mainstream media to cheerlead for and relay every word uttered by Gov. Beshear and his staffers without question, while at the same time challenging everything said and done by President Trump and his administration. In this day and age of what everyone calls "the new normal," the old normal perseveres when it shouldn't.